TL;DR: Large merchants should assess payment fees alongside authorization, conversion or checkout drop-off, fraud, false positives, chargebacks, and resilience. Segment results by market, channel, payment method, and provider to locate costs and customer losses, then prioritize changes that fit the business. BCG's survey describes respondent practices and outcomes; it does not prove that one operating model causes better results.

  • Compare payment fees with authorization, checkout drop-off, fraud, false positives, and chargebacks; fee reductions alone do not show whether performance improved.
  • Segment results by market, channel, payment method, and provider to locate where costs or customer losses occur.
  • Treat orchestration and a single-acquirer model as context-dependent choices; the source examples show both as deliberate approaches.
  • Assign owners to selected changes and track customer outcomes alongside payment costs.

Payment performance improves when merchants assess costs alongside lost sales and customer impact – not when they focus on fees alone. In BCG’s 2026 survey of nearly 500 large merchants, 79% said payments costs had risen over the previous five years, while fewer than one in ten said they had reduced them. Those findings point to a gap: professionalizing payments has not, by itself, guaranteed lower costs or better results.

Large merchants should assess payment fees alongside authorization, conversion or checkout drop-off, fraud, false positives, chargebacks, and resilience. Segment results by market, channel, payment method, and provider to locate costs and customer losses, then prioritize changes that fit the business. BCG’s survey describes respondent practices and outcomes; it does not prove that one operating model causes better results.

For large merchants, the practical task is to compare fees with authorization rates, checkout drop-off, fraud, false positives, chargebacks, and resilience. Break the results down by market, channel, payment method, and provider. That helps leaders locate both payment costs and customer losses before deciding which changes fit their business.

BCG presents its merchant analysis as the third chapter of a four-part annual report on the global payments industry and the trends shaping its future (BCG’s 2026 Global Payments Report). The full report is titled The Burden of Proof and is available as a PDF (BCG’s report information). The survey results describe its respondents, not all merchants, and do not establish that a particular operating model causes better performance.

Why hasn’t a professional payments function guaranteed better payment performance?

A dedicated team can give payments clear ownership, but the survey suggests that this alone does not resolve rising costs. BCG defined large merchants in the survey as companies with annual revenue ranging from millions to billions. Among those respondents, 79% reported higher payments costs over the previous five years, and fewer than one in ten said they had brought costs down.

For 72% of surveyed large merchants, the payments mandate still centered on reducing complexity and controlling costs. That focus matters, but it can leave customer outcomes out of the decision. A lower fee is not a complete improvement if authorization weakens, more customers abandon checkout, or fraud controls wrongly stop legitimate purchases.

What does the survey show about merchant operating models?

Survey respondents more often had individual payments capabilities than a model combining them. 89% had dedicated payments teams, 43% used dynamic orchestration or a deliberately chosen single-acquirer model, and 28% treated payments as a profit center. Only 12% combined all three. These are survey results, not universal benchmarks.

Folded paper planes meet at an amber hinge to form a continuous bridge.
Folded paper planes meet at an amber hinge to form a continuous bridge.

The distinction is important. Orchestration coordinates payment routing across providers; a single-acquirer approach makes a deliberate choice to work with one provider. The survey does not show that one model is inherently better. It indicates that the combination of accountable teams, an intentionally selected acquiring approach, and profit-center management was uncommon among respondents.

Merchants that treated payments as a profit center were more likely to track authorization rates, by 21 percentage points; false-positive fraud rates, by 17 points; and conversion, by 12 points. They were also more likely to review acquirers annually, by 8 points. The 12% combining all three practices reported conversion and authorization success rates 2 percentage points above the survey average, fraud rates 0.5 percentage point lower, and a share of transactions stopped by fraud controls 1 percentage point lower. These are observed associations, not proof that the operating model caused the differences.

How should merchants measure payment costs and customer losses?

Compare the cost of processing with the customer and transaction outcomes it supports. Review fees alongside authorization, conversion or checkout drop-off, fraud, false positives, and chargebacks. Segment each measure by market, channel, payment method, and provider so an overall average does not conceal where costs or lost sales are concentrated.

An amber-pivoted paper balance holds dark fee sheets opposite layered white sheets.AI GENERATED
An amber-pivoted paper balance holds dark fee sheets opposite layered white sheets.

False positives belong in that assessment. Payment systems may wrongly decline 2% to 5% of legitimate transactions, while nearly half of merchants never quantify those declines. A fraud measure that counts prevented fraud but ignores legitimate customers turned away leaves part of the performance picture missing.

Provider performance also merits deliberate review. About half of surveyed merchants benchmarked their acquirers annually, and 44% had switched or added a provider in the previous five years. Among providers named as a primary acquirer by at least ten respondents, the share of very satisfied merchants ranged from 17% to 71%. These survey findings make the case for judging providers against a merchant’s own results rather than assuming that an established relationship remains the right fit.

Where should payments leaders make deliberate choices?

BCG’s five practice areas cover the customer experience, acquiring, fraud, resilience, and revenue opportunities. The right decisions depend on the business; the examples do not establish a single best model.

  1. Make checkout straightforward and payment options appropriate. Consider whether the checkout experience and available payment methods suit your customers. BCG also asks merchants to test whether their setup can support AI-led discovery and agent-initiated purchases. That is a limited readiness consideration, not a broader technology programme.
  2. Choose an acquiring model that fits the business. A leading French sports brand uses in-house orchestration and smart routing across multiple providers. Louis Vuitton took a different approach, consolidating in-store and online payments with a single global acquirer. These examples show context-dependent choices, not a ranking of models or a case for adding providers by default.
  3. Consider revenue opportunities only when they fit. Co-branded cards require sufficient scale, loyalty, and engagement. Embedded finance depends on proprietary data and direct integration, and BCG describes it as a better fit for marketplaces and platforms. The report mentions Netflix’s payments approach alongside monthly churn of 2% to 3%; it does not establish that payments alone caused that churn level.

How can merchants turn payment findings into priorities?

Start by locating costs and customer losses across markets, channels, payment methods, and providers. Compare the measures that matter to your business, including fees, authorization, checkout conversion or drop-off, fraud, false positives, chargebacks, and resilience. A global fashion and sports retailer analyzed its five most important markets and reported savings equal to 15% to 20% of its annual payments costs. That is a source example, not a typical outcome or forecast for other merchants.

Next, decide what to change and who should deliver it. Benchmark providers, assess whether the acquiring model still fits, and determine what to invest in, keep in-house, or source externally. The survey’s findings on annual reviews and provider changes offer context for that assessment; they do not prescribe a review cadence for every merchant.

Then coordinate the selected priorities across the teams responsible for delivering them, with clear ownership and tracking. Keep cost and customer outcomes visible together so that a fee reduction does not obscure lost sales or a worse payment experience.

Frequently asked questions

Should a merchant use orchestration or one global acquirer?

Neither approach is inherently best. The source contrasts a leading French sports brand’s in-house orchestration across multiple providers with Louis Vuitton’s single-global-acquirer model for in-store and online payments. Choose based on business context and measured performance, not a general rule that more providers or fewer providers are always better.

Which measures should a merchant compare by market, channel, method, and provider?

Compare payment fees with authorization, conversion or checkout drop-off, fraud, false positives, and chargebacks. Include resilience in the wider assessment. Reviewing these measures together helps identify where payments create costs and where they may be costing the business legitimate transactions or customer confidence.

Key takeaways

  • Compare payment fees with authorization, checkout drop-off, fraud, false positives, and chargebacks; fee reductions alone do not show whether performance improved.
  • Segment results by market, channel, payment method, and provider to locate where costs or customer losses occur.
  • Treat orchestration and a single-acquirer model as context-dependent choices; the source examples show both as deliberate approaches.
  • Assign owners to selected changes and track customer outcomes alongside payment costs.

Practical tips

  • Include legitimate transactions declined by fraud controls in performance reviews, not only measures of fraud stopped.
  • Benchmark providers against your own results across relevant markets, channels, and payment methods.
  • When considering co-branded cards or embedded finance, account for the stated prerequisites: scale, loyalty, and engagement for cards; proprietary data and direct integration for embedded finance.



Related Posts

Contact

Slovak Republic+421911948347

DATATIP, s.r.o.
Alžbetina 30
Košice 040 01
Company ID: 36869112
VAT ID: SK2023131594
IBAN: SK80 8330 0000 0022 0024 5482

Czech Republic+420773926377

DATATIP CZ, s.r.o.
Pelušková 1443
Praha 198 00
Company ID: 24853577
VAT ID: CZ24853577
IBAN: CZ81 2010 0000 0023 0033 8790

Privacy Preference Center